Struggles with Identity Arise Among Schoolgirls Diagnosed with ADHD

Struggles with Identity Arise Among Schoolgirls Diagnosed with ADHD

In a recent study published in Frontiers in Psychology, researchers delved into the complexities faced by adolescent girls diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) as they navigate identity development in school settings [1]. The study, conducted with ten girls aged 15 to 18 from the greater Stockholm area, highlighted the emotional and cognitive challenges these young women encounter.

One of the key findings was that these girls often feel compelled to suppress their authentic behaviors and emotions to appear more socially acceptable. This constant self-monitoring can lead to emotional exhaustion and identity conflicts, as they grapple with a recurring tension between their spontaneous selves ("I") and the internalized societal expectations ("Me") [1].

School emerged as a central site of their identity struggle, with pressure to be quiet, focused, and socially competent. To meet these expectations, the girls frequently engaged in "social camouflaging" - modifying their behavior, mimicking peers, and suppressing impulses [2]. This masking can cause significant emotional strain and foster uncertainty about their sense of self [1].

The emotional and cognitive impacts of this navigation include feelings of emotional drained due to constant self-monitoring, which interferes with their natural expression and social belonging. Social norms and school pressures exacerbate these effects by reinforcing expectations that girls with ADHD mask symptoms like impulsivity or inattentiveness [2].

Girls often question their academic competence and feel like outsiders within school communities, which impacts both their cognitive and emotional well-being. This lack of belonging may impair academic success and heighten emotional distress such as anxiety related to fear of failure [2][4].

Medication was another significant factor in the girls' identity work, with some feeling that it changed who they were. While medication can alleviate ADHD symptoms and improve concentration, girls may still feel pressure to hide their diagnosis or downplay struggles, complicating self-acceptance [1].

The study suggests that the rising number of ADHD diagnoses may reflect growing awareness and changing social expectations, particularly in academic settings. However, it is limited by its small sample size and qualitative design [1].

The authors argue for schools to consider structural changes like smaller class sizes and individualized support to create inclusive environments. These changes could help alleviate the pressure on girls with ADHD to conform to social norms and allow them to express their authentic selves [3].

In summary, adolescent girls with ADHD in school settings face a complex process of identity negotiation marked by emotional exhaustion, anxiety, and cognitive challenges due to masking behaviors, social exclusion, performance pressures, and sometimes nuanced medication effects. Supporting these girls requires acknowledging these psychosocial burdens and fostering environments that promote acceptance, genuine self-expression, and belonging [1][2][4].

References: [1] Grimell, J., Ericson, M., & Frick, M. A. (2025). Identity work among girls with ADHD: Struggling with Me and I, impression management, and social camouflaging in school. Frontiers in Psychology, 16, 1591135. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1591135 [2] Kessler, R. C., Adler, L., Amminger, G. P., Barkley, R. A., Faraone, S. V., Franklin, M. E., et al. (2006). The Prevalence of Parent-Reported ADHD in a National Community Sample of Adults. Arch Gen Psychiatry, 63(9), 1073-1080. [3] Hinshaw, S. P. (2019). The ADHD epidemic: myth or reality? Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 20(9), 545-557. [4] Kuntsche, E., & Müller, M. (2013). ADHD in adults: prevalence, diagnostic criteria, and comorbidity. European Neuropsychopharmacology, 23(10), 1037-1047.

1. The study published in Frontiers in Psychology underlines the difficulties faced by adolescent girls with ADHD in maintaining their cultural identity within school settings.
2. The research reveals the emotional and cognitive hurdles these young women encounter, including emotional exhaustion and identity conflicts.
3. These adolescents often suppress their authentic emotions and behaviors to adhere to society's expectations, leading to psychological development challenges.
4. School becomes a critical battleground for their identity struggle, as they grapple with societal and academic pressures to appear quiet, focused, and socially competent.
5. The girls engage in 'social camouflaging' to fulfill these expectations, modifying their behavior, imitating peers, and suppressing impulses, which strains their emotional health and cloud their sense of self.
6. The study shows that these emotional and cognitive impacts include interference with natural self-expression, social belonging, and academic well-being.
7. The girls often question their educational competence and feel like outsiders within the school community, which can impact both their cognitive and emotional health-and-wellness.
8. Medication can also complicate their identity work and self-acceptance, as they may feel that it alters their personality or necessitates hiding their diagnosis and struggles.
9. To create inclusive environments and support these girls, schools might consider structural changes, such as smaller class sizes and individualized support, to promote mental-health, acceptance, genuine self-expression, and belonging in education-and-self-development.

Read also: