Skip to content

Age-Based Crisis Unfolding

Donaldson's first directorial film premiere unfolded at the 2024 Sundance Festival, portraying a family excursion in nature transformed into a coming-of-age narrative tainted with the usual life disillusionments. Coverage by Yulia Shagelman.

Conflict Across Generations
Conflict Across Generations

Age-Based Crisis Unfolding

**

The much-anticipated 2024 film directed by India Donaldson, titled "Good One," is a poignant coming-of-age drama that takes audiences on a journey through the Catskill Mountains. Starring Lily Collins (more precisely Lily Collias) as 17-year-old Sam, the film delves into the complexities of growing up, family dynamics, and the emotional weight of disappointment[1][3][4].

Set over three days, "Good One" follows Sam as she embarks on a hiking trip with her father, Chris (played by James Le Gros), and his friend Matt (played by Danny McCarthy). As the trip unfolds, the narrative weaves together moments of breathtaking beauty and palpable tension, culminating in emotional confrontations and personal epiphanies[1][4].

The film's tone is more contemplative than thriller-like, emphasizing internal struggles and interpersonal anxieties rather than external dangers[1][4]. Lily Collias delivers an outstanding performance as Sam, bringing depth to her character's journey through the natural setting, which symbolizes the challenges and uncertainties of growing up[1][3].

Sam's relationship with her father is at the heart of the story. She offers him advice on improving his relationship with his son, drawing from her own experience as a child of divorced parents. Despite being 17, Sam displays maturity and empathy towards her father and Matt, navigating the burdens that grow heavier as the trip progresses[2][3].

The portrayal of Sam's despair and pain is done subtly without exaggeration, a testament to Donaldson's skillful direction. Sam turns to her father for support and protection, but he admits his own unreliability, adding another layer of emotional complexity to the narrative[2][3].

The film premiered at the Sundance Festival in 2024, marking Donaldson’s feature debut. The cinematography, handled by Wilson Cameron, captures simple and unpretentious shots of the characters' activities, immersing viewers in the rugged beauty of the Catskill Mountains[1][4].

Yulia Shagelman tells the story in the film, with Sam's journey serving as a metaphor for the struggle to find one's place in the world amidst the complexities of family and personal growth. After a brief introduction, it is evident that Sam will manage on her own, but Donaldson allows her to remain a child for a while longer before stepping into the adult world[2].

The recent divorce between Matt and his son Dylan has left fresh and painful mutual grudges between them, adding another layer of tension to the trip[3]. Despite the mature themes and complex relationships, "Good One" is a family-centered drama that offers a nuanced exploration of adolescent emotions and family relationships within a hiking trip framework.

  1. The poignant coming-of-age drama, "Good One," directed by India Donaldson, embodies the journey of personal growth, delving into the complexities of relationships, family-dynamics, and growing up.
  2. Lily Collias delivers a stellar performance in "Good One," portraying the emotional weight of growing up, set against the backdrop of education and self-development.
  3. Movies and TV enthusiasts seeking entertainment with an emphasis on relationships and personal growth should put "Good One" on their must-watch list.
  4. Beyond its hiking trip framework, "Good One" offers a nuanced exploration of entertainment and social issues, including family-dynamics, adolescent emotions, and the pursuit of personal growth.

Read also:

    Latest